It all started with a joint lawsuit the Indiana governor filled against the U.S. government. Nate Chute/IndyStar
Mike Pence wants his communications limited from public access. Experts say this sets a "dangerous precedent."
Gov. Mike Pence(Photo: IndyStar file photo)
Now that the presidential campaign and most of the furor over Hillary Clinton's email scandal are behind us, the Pence administration is going to court to argue for its own brand of email secrecy.
The administration is fighting to conceal the contents of an email sent to Gov. Mike Pence by a political ally. That email is being sought by a prominent Democratic labor lawyer who says he wants to expose waste in the Republican administration.
But legal experts fear the stakes may be much higher than mere politics because the decision could remove a judicial branch check on executive power and limit a citizen's right to know what the government is doing and how it spends taxpayer dollars.
"It comes down to this — the court is giving up its ability to check another branch of government, and that should worry people," said Gerry Lanosga, an Indiana University media professor specializing in public records law.
In the case, Indianapolis attorney William Groth is appealing a decision handed down by Marion Superior Court in April, which decided that redactions the administration made to a public record could not be second-guessed by the court.
The focal point in the case is a political “white paper” that had been excluded from Groth’s public records request.
Pence’s legal defense team claims the white paper is attorney work product protected by Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act — and at the end of the day, matters of public records are not for a court to decide.
Groth argues the lower court misapplied the law.
“I think governmental transparency is an important concern of anyone who lives in a democracy – the governor cannot put himself above the law,” Groth told the IndyStar.
How the case came about
The matter stems from a lawsuit filed after President Barack Obama announced in November 2014 that he was taking new steps to "fix America’s broken immigration system." Those steps included offering deferred enforcement of immigration laws for parents of children born in the United States, and for children who entered the United States before they were 16 years old.
The action drew the ire of Republican governors across the country, including Pence, who called the policy a "profound mistake."
Pence, joined in on a lawsuit led by Texas Gov. Greg Abbot in State of Texas, et al v. United States, with the blessing of the Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller. Zoeller's office did not respond to IndyStar requests for comment.
Pence hired Indianapolis law firm Barnes & Thornburg to join the Texas litigation. A representative from the firm — which is also representing Pence in this case — did not respond to IndyStar requests for interview.
In December 2014, Groth requested information regarding Pence's decision to hire outside counsel and the cost to Indiana taxpayers.
"I think joining the lawsuit without the attorney general and hiring that firm was a waste of taxpayer dollars and the people have the right to know how much of their money was spent,” Groth said. Groth is known in Indiana for representing the plaintiffs in the 2008 U.S. Supreme Court voter identification case, Crawford v. Marion County Election Board.
Pence produced the documents in the request “but those documents included substantial redaction,” according to court documents.
The 57-page response also included an email that Daniel Hodge, Abbott's chief of staff, sent to 30 recipients in various states asking them to join the lawsuit against Obama.
The message included an attached white paper, but the governor failed to produce the document, according to court records.
After a yearlong trial, the Superior Court held that the issue was not a matter for the courts to decide, citing a Indiana Supreme Court case decided just days before.
In a 4-1 ruling, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled in Citizens Action Coalition, et al. v. Indiana House Rep., that under
the Indiana Constitution’s separation of powers clause the legislature's redactions were nonjusticiable, a legal term that means not for the court to decide. Groth was also the attorney representing the plaintiffs in that case.
Groth appealed in June and the Indiana Court of Appeals will hear oral arguments Nov. 21 at 1 p.m. at the Statehouse, where each side will be allowed 20 minutes for arguments.FacebookTwitterGoogle+LinkedInGet to know the VP: A look at Mike Pence> Fullscreen
A link has been posted to your Facebook feed.
Like this topic? You may also like these photo galleries:
- 1 of 81
- 2 of 81
- 3 of 81
- 4 of 81
- 5 of 81
- 6 of 81
- 7 of 81
- 8 of 81
- 9 of 81
- 10 of 81
- 11 of 81
- 12 of 81
- 13 of 81
- 14 of 81
- 15 of 81
- 16 of 81
- 17 of 81
- 18 of 81
- 19 of 81
- 20 of 81
- 21 of 81
- 22 of 81
- 23 of 81
- 24 of 81
- 25 of 81
- 26 of 81
- 27 of 81
- 28 of 81
- 29 of 81
- 30 of 81
- 31 of 81
- 32 of 81
- 33 of 81
- 34 of 81
- 35 of 81
- 36 of 81
- 37 of 81
- 38 of 81
- 39 of 81
- 40 of 81
- 41 of 81
- 42 of 81
- 43 of 81
- 44 of 81
- 45 of 81
- 46 of 81
- 47 of 81
- 48 of 81
- 49 of 81
- 50 of 81
- 51 of 81
- 52 of 81
- 53 of 81
- 54 of 81
- 55 of 81
- 56 of 81
- 57 of 81
- 58 of 81
- 59 of 81
- 60 of 81
- 61 of 81
- 62 of 81
- 63 of 81
- 64 of 81
- 65 of 81
- 66 of 81
- 67 of 81
- 68 of 81
- 69 of 81
- 70 of 81
- 71 of 81
- 72 of 81
- 73 of 81
- 74 of 81
- 75 of 81
- 76 of 81
- 77 of 81
- 78 of 81
- 79 of 81
- 80 of 81
- 81 of 81
'A dangerous legal precedent'
Paul Jefferson, a former professor of state constitutional law at the Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law, said the major question for the appellate court to decide is "whether they're going to extend that (Citizens Action Coalition, et al. v. Indiana House Rep.) to the executive branch as a whole."
He said if the court rules in favor of the governor, "that would severely limit the Access to Public Records Act."
It's a fear that even the highest levels of court have warned about.
In the sole dissent of the Citizens Action Coalition lawsuit, Indiana Supreme Court Justice Justice Robert Rucker stated: “The majority’s ruling is not only premature, but it unfortunately weighs in on a significant separation of powers issue without an adequate record.”
The state's public access counselor, Luke Britt, appointed by Pence in 2013, also fears what might happen if other public officials invoke the Citizens Action Coalition privilege. "After that case, a lot of local government officials were trying to claim a similar privilege — that was one of my fears."
Jefferson said that "this will be interesting in part because it is hard to draw clean lines between what would be and what wouldn’t be if excluded from a public records request if the court is going to exempt the executive branch from public records review."
Lanosga, the public access professor, says the outcome of the case will set a precedent on what are appropriate levels of transparency in government.
"It shows no accountability," he said, "that an agency can say things are exempt just because and citizens have no recourse."
Call IndyStar reporter Fatima Hussein at (317) 444-6209. Follow her on Twitter:@fatimathefatima.
Pence could play influential role as the next vice president
Next VP: 10 things to know about Indiana Gov. Mike Pence
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump takes aim at Elizabeth Warren's brainchild | 0:44
Donald Trump is reportedly setting his sights on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, an agency proposed by Elizabeth Warren as part of Wall Street reform. Buzz601 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Sonny Perdue Is Trump’s pick for agriculture secretary | 0:28
Perdue served on Trump's agricultural advisory committee during the presidential campaign. USA TODAY NETWORK2 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump signs over family business to sons | 0:37
President-elect Trump explains why his sons will run the Trump family business while he occupies the White House.3 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump's cabinet selections | 1:33
Several of Donald Trump's staff selections will begin to undergo Senate confirmation hearings in the final days leading up to the president-elect's inauguration. Time4 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Ivanka Trump reportedly cuts ties with her businesses | 0:53
Ivanka Trump will reportedly cut ties with her fashion brand as well as her role in the Trump Organization. Veuer's Nick Cardona has more. Buzz605 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump hopeful on jobs, Cabinet after meetings | 1:49
President-elect Donald Trump predicts all of his Cabinet picks will win Senate confirmation. This comes as he wrapped up two meetings with foreign business leaders and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. (Jan. 9) AP6 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump picks Wall Street lawyer to head SEC | 0:43
Jay Clayton is a partner at Sullivan & Cromwell in New York City and has represented some big Wall Street names. Video provided by Newsy Newslook7 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump challenges intel agencies he'll oversee | 1:27
President-elect Donald Trump escalated his blunt public challenge to the U.S. intelligence agencies he will soon oversee, appearing to embrace assertions that Russia did not provide the hacked Democratic emails that roiled the 2016 election. (Jan. 4) AP8 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump picks a China hawk for his trade representative | 0:53
Veteran trade negotiator Robert Lighthizer will oversee the Trump administration's trade policies and negotiations. Video provided by Newsy Newslook9 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION 'Apprentice' star Omarosa joining Trump in White House | 0:28
Former "Apprentice" star and Trump campaign surrogate Omarosa Manigault is reportedly joining Donald Trump's White House staff. Wochit10 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Kellyanne Conway: Trump's pick for White House counselor | 0:54
Trump's former campaign manager will be the highest-ranking woman in the White House. USA TODAY NETWORK11 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Billionaire Carl Icahn to join Team Trump | 0:30
Carl Icahn, whose net worth is said to be $21.6 billion, endorsed Trump awhile back and was repeatedly mentioned as a potential Treasury secretary pick. USA TODAY12 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump wants Secretary of the Army to be Vincent Viola | 0:28
President-elect Donald Trump has announced that he is nominating Vincent Viola, the founder of Virtu Financial, to be the Secretary of the Army. USA TODAY13 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Representative Ryan Zinke chosen to be interior secretary | 0:36
According to reports, U.S. President-elect Donald Trump has chosen Republican Montana Representative Ryan Zinke to be his interior secretary. USA TODAY14 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION David Friedman: Trump's pick for Ambassador to Israel | 0:34
President-elect Donald Trump described David Friedman as a "long-time friend and trusted advisor," but one of Friedman's goals is already causing controversy. Wochit15 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump picks Ronna Romney McDaniel as RNC head | 0:42
Donald Trump has selected Ronna Romney McDaniel to lead the Republican National Committee. McDaniel, who currently chairs the Michigan Republican Party, is the niece of 2012 GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney. Wochit16 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Rick Perry: Trump's reported pick for Energy secretary | 0:55
President-elect Donald Trump will reportedly tap former Republican presidential rival Rick Perry to head up the U.S. Department of Energy. It's the same department the former governor once wanted to eliminate. USA TODAY NETWORK17 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Bill Gates spoke with Donald Trump about climate change | 0:59
Bill Gates spoke with Donald Trump about climate change, as well as medicine and education. Time18 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Sources: Trump to Name Tillerson Sec. of State | 1:11
Sources tell the Associated Press that President-elect Donald Trump will name Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson Secretary of State on Tuesday. Tillerson could face a difficult confirmation, due to his connections with Russia. (Dec. 13) AP19 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump slams Lockheed Martin over F-35 Cost overruns | 1:54
Donald Trump has taken to Twitter to criticize Lockheed Martin for cost overruns for its delayed F-35 fighter program. Newslook20 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Gary Cohn: Trump's pick for economic adviser | 0:37
Add another Goldman Sachs employee to Trump's cabinet. Wochit21 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Report: Donald Trump considering Bobby Valentine for U.S. ambassador to Japan | 0:39
Former Mets and Red Sox skipper and current Sacred Heart University athletic director Bobby Valentine is on the short list of candidates for United States ambassador to Japan, WEEI in Boston reports. Time_Sports22 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Giuliani removes himself from Cabinet consideration | 0:41
Once thought to be a strong candidate for Secretary of State, Rudy Giuliani has removed his name from consideration for any Cabinet post in the new administration. USA TODAY23 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump transition aide names Iowa Governor as China ambassador | 0:44
A transition aide confirmed Wednesday President-elect Donald Trump has offered Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad the job of ambassador to China. USA TODAY24 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Andrew Puzder expected to be named as Trump's Labor Secretary | 0:39
Fast-food executive Andrew Puzder is the leading candidate for the Labor Secretary job within the Trump administration, according to sources familiar with the selection process. USA TODAY25 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump's choice to lead EPA has a history with the agency | 0:45
Scott Pruitt has called EPA regulations "coercion" and has fought to slow down the move away from fossil fuels. Video provided by Newsy Newslook26 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Retired General John Kelly: Trump's pick for Homeland Security | 0:33
President-elect Trump has made his pick for the top U.S. security position: retired Marine General John Kelly. He is the third retired general and second Marine picked by Trump for top-level administration positions. USA TODAY27 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump officially announces Pentagon pick Mattis | 2:22
President-elect Donald Trump is officially announcing he will nominate retired Marine Gen. James Mattis to be his Defense Secretary, bringing his pick onstage in North Carolina. (Dec. 6) AP28 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Former Sen. Bob Dole had a lot to do with Trump's call with Taiwan | 0:47
Bob Dole lobbied Donald Trump's campaign in favor of improved relations with Taiwan, and he made money doing it. Newslook29 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Raw: Sen. Majority leader meets Trump's CIA pick | 0:30
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell met with President-elect Donald Trump's pick for director of the Central Intelligence Agency. (Dec. 5) AP30 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Ben Carson: Trump's pick for housing secretary | 1:00
President-elect Donald Trump has nominated former GOP rival Dr. Ben Carson to be secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development. USA TODAY NETWORK31 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Al Gore had an 'extremely interesting' meeting with Donald Trump | 0:40
Al Gore and Donald Trump had a brief meeting Monday, presumably about Trump's position on climate change. Newsy32 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump's nominee for health secretary Price vows change | 0:45
US President-elect Donald Trump nominated fierce Obamacare critic, Tom Price as health secretary, indicating he plans to fulfill a campaign promise to tear up the divisive healthcare reform law. Video provided by AFP Newslook33 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Palin seems eager to win a spot in Trump's cabinet | 1:27
She shared a video touting her commitment to veterans after reports surfaced that she's being considered for secretary of Veterans Affairs. Newslook34 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Mnuchin: What we know about Trump's pick for Treasury | 0:52
Steven Mnuchin, a hedge fund manager and former Goldman Sachs executive, is President-elect Donald Trump's choice for Treasury secretary, a source told USA TODAY. Here is what we know about the 53-year-old. USA TODAY NETWORK35 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Wilbur Ross: A look at Trump's pick for Commerce secretary | 0:38
Donald Trump's pick for Commerce secretary is billionaire businessman Wilbur Ross. Here is what we know about the 'King of Bankruptcy.' USA TODAY NETWORK36 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump makes pick to head U.S. Department of Health And Human Services | 0:53
U.S. Rep. Tom Price is an outspoken critic of Obamacare. Video provided by Newsy Newslook37 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump taps Elaine Chao for Transportation Secretary position | 0:29
The former Secretary of Labor and wife to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell will be joining the Trump administration. USA TODAY38 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Meet the two newest additions to the Trump team | 0:48
Fox News analyst KT McFarland and lawyer Don McGahn are the two latest additions to Donald Trump's White House. Video provided by Newsy Newslook39 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Kellyanne Conway publicly slams Mitt Romney as potential Secretary of | 0:48
President-elect Donald Trump senior adviser Kellyanne Conway says she has personal concerns with the prospect of Mitt Romney being selected as secretary of state. Time40 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Betsy DeVos: Trump's pick for Education secretary | 0:50
Donald Trump has selected Michigan Republican, Betsy DeVos, for Secretary of Education. Here is what we know about her. USA TODAY NETWORK41 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Wilbur Ross expected to be tapped for Commerce secretary | 0:40
Billionaire investor Wilbur Ross is expected to be President-elect Donald Trump's choice for Commerce secretary, a senior transition official said. Trump met with Ross on Sunday at his New Jersey golf club. AP42 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Sources: Trump taps Gov. Haley for U.N. ambassador | 0:45
President-elect Donald Trump has selected South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley as ambassador to the United Nations, and he will treat it as a cabinet-level position. That’s according to two sources familiar with Trump’s decision. (Nov. 23) AP43 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump wants a 'cordial and productive' relationship with the media | 0:58
Donald Trump had a few choice words for top executives and anchors from several major TV news networks. But it seems he also wanted to make peace. Video provided by Newsy Newslook44 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Will the Trumps live in The White House? | 1:30
Speculation has been growing over how much time Donald Trump will spend in New York City. Newslook45 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump lays out 100 day plan in new video | 2:37
President-elect Donald Trump shares a specific agenda for his first 100 days in office in a newly uploaded video to his transition team's Facebook page.46 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump meets harsh critic Mitt Romney at N.J. golf course | 1:01
Trump was meeting Saturday with one of his sharpest Republican critics of the campaign, 2012 presidential candidate Mitt Romney, at Trump’s golf club in New Jersey. Time47 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Steve Bannon: A closer look at Trump's chief strategist | 1:04
President-elect Donald Trump's chief strategist Stephen Bannon is causing a social media firestorm with his controversial commentary and projects. Let's take a closer look at some of his past positions. USA TODAY NETWORK48 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump's inauguration team | 0:23
Here's a look at some of the major players on Donald Trump's inauguration team. USA TODAY49 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Michael Flynn: Trump's pick for national security adviser | 1:31
Michael Flynn would be an addition to Trump's cabinet that has many top Democrats on edge. USA TODAY, Collin Brennan50 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION What Trump and Putin discussed over the phone | 0:28
President-elect Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin spoke on the phone on Monday to discuss the future of the US-Russia relationship. USA TODAY51 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Justice Ginsburg: Trump will fill court vacancy | 2:25
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg is acknowledging that the outcome of last week's election means that Donald Trump will fill the 9-month-old Supreme Court vacancy. Ginsburg did not otherwise comment on the presidential election Monday. (Nov. 14) AP52 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump could be aiming for a little more diversity on his team | 1:17
Donald Trump is reportedly considering appointing an openly gay man as U.N. ambassador and a woman as RNC chair. Video provided by Newsy Newslook53 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump meets with Nigel Farage | 1:44
The UKIP leader has told his country's government that he is happy to "provide introductions" to the U.S. President-elect. Time54 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Priebus Tapped as White House Chief of Staff | 0:52
President-elect Donald Trump has chosen Republican Party Chairman Reince Priebus as his White House chief of staff and conservative media executive Stephen Bannon as his senior counselor. (Nov. 13) AP55 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump plans to deport up to 3 million immigrants | 0:42
President-elect Donald Trump said he plans to deport about two to three million undocumented immigrants, speaking in a pre-taped interview that will air Sunday night. Time56 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump campaign manager discusses transition | 2:12
Without offering details, Donald Trump's presidential election campaign manager, Kellyanne Conway said Trump will build "a fabulous cabinet, filled with people who are qualified to do this job and understand very clearly what his goals are." (Nov. 12) AP57 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Donald Trump says he’s willing to preserve parts of Obamacare | 0:48
President-elect Donald Trump, who had repeatedly campaigned on a promise to repeal the Affordable Care Act, said Friday that he would consider keeping certain parts of the health care law after meeting with President Obama at the White House. Time58 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION US president-elect Trump holds transition meetings | 0:30
Donald Trump shakes up his White House transition team, appointing running mate Mike Pence to head the process of filling key administration posts, and demoting New Jersey Governor Chris Christie to a deputy role. Video provided by AFP Newslook59 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Mike Pence will lead Donald Trump’s transition team | 0:52
The vice president-elect will replace Chris Christie and head Donald Trump's transition team. Time60 of 61
ShareTRUMP IN TRANSITION Trump seems to be backtracking on a few of his agenda items | 1:07
Donald Trump told The Wall Street Journal he might keep some provisions of President Obama's health care law after all. Video provided by Newsy Newslook
Source : http://www.jsonline.com/story/news/2016/11/14/whats-mike-pence-hiding-his-emails/92839560/